Friday, December 23, 2005

Am I morally wrong?
I've been criticized with having made a "gradual descent into your alternate reality of moral superiority" and not fearing recourse for what I say.
Basically, I don't think I've put myself on a pedestal. I've said time and time again, that I'm a bastard or whatnot, not to be self-pitying or funny, rather pointing out that I do realise that I do make mistakes, and am certainly not a good person.
In all honesty, I have been hard pressed to find morality on the internet. It is but a quick glance into different worlds, different lives. The morality brought up by the internet is on issues surrounding internet habits, like pornography, and fraud (whether it be a pedophile posing as a child or stealing credit card information). Im not here to say that this is terrible, regardless of how I feel. And Im certainly not here to say that this blog is any different from the rest of the internet. Im not using my blog to make the world a better place. I have been using it as a sounding board.
HOW many times have I pleaded for people to give me valued feedback on things I say, opinions I hold?!? Still, those who are the ones really passing judgement are sitting back and passing that judgement silently on me, or perhaps they will post emotional defensive comments when I have made mistakes and offended people.
I will attempt to sum up why my relations with Richard are such a big deal to me:
I took lessons with Richard for a long time, as a result, I owe him worlds of gratitude for developing me into the musician I am today. I also owe him to the development of me as a person, he taught me not only how to play, but how to appreciate and love music. Richard was never a just clinical teacher who would just sit back and listen to you play and tell you how to play better. He certainly became a father figure to me, someone who loved me and could understand how much music meant to me, more than actual members of my family ever will. When it came time to go to university, I knew I would have to stop taking lessons with him and go to one of the university teachers. I didn't want to stop altogether, so I started with Organ lessons. All around this time, I heard warnings about what The school of music at U of M does to people. And specifically I heard the story about one of his former students who, while at school, started treating Richard badly and acted as if he was better than Richard. It wasn't til after he moved away to a new school that he realised his ignorance. Many times I was told this story with the 'don't let it happen to you' warning implied.
All along, this idea has been with me. I've tried to be conscious of my views and whatnot, to avoid becoming snobby like the story. Importantly, I asked those close to me to keep an eye on changes in my personality and musical ideals. I asked people from school, Richard, his son, and Andy-Pandy to keep me in check. If in fact I have been making a "gradual descent into your alternate reality of moral superiority" such as Richard warned, please tell me. I will be dissapointed with myself and also with those around me who saw this coming but spared me for whatever reason.
When I stopped taking lessons with Richard, it was a very difficult decision and even more difficult to tell him. He took it very badly and we didn't talk for months. Even though it was my decision to stop the lessons, when Richard took this as a personal thing, our relationship died. I lost my musical father. more than that, I was disowned by him.
Things have gotten better slowly, but it's empty. I have no idea what he thinks of me anymore, and I've been struggling with that since.
Especially to those close to this situation, please just simply answer me this:
Have I changed in a bad way? Has what I've been trying to do as musical development actually turned me into a snobby musician?

I appologize. I hope that the damage I have done is not irreversible. If I have turned into a snobby, bad person, i shall be disturbed by the fact that I am in fact a bad person, and I ask those who care to help me to change.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

my dear friend michael:
perhaps i have not known you long enough to say if you have indeed changed or not, but i will take the liberties of sharing my opinion.
when one falls in love with music, it is a complete encompassing of the mind soul and heart. You have fallen in love with it, i see it in your eyes and hear it in your playing.
one of the many pitfalls of performing is pride, especially when you are a talented performer as you are. We have to find the fine line of balance between confidence in ourselves and our craft, and a humble and modest approach to the music. To allow it to guide us and to slowly show us its hidden beauties. it is easy to turn into a snobby musician, and in my short time in the musical environment i have seen this happen too many times.
I have seen you work hard, and improve, and be proud of the work that you have done, and rightly so. but if i were asked if your musical quest had warped you i would instantly reply "no".
as we learn music we grow and change, not because we are trying to, but because it is inevitable. There are some who have disliked the changes in me, but I have accepted them as part of who I am now.
There will always be people who try to force you not to change, but those people would have you die. Change scares the shit out of people, and to embrace music is to embrace that change.
Michael, you've embraced the music, and it will always be a struggle to remain true to it, not to selfish ambition, but you can do it. let it change you and you'll see it....and all the peeps who disagree can go...*insert german phrase here*
...sorry if this is all a little melodramatic...thats just who i am ... this week....*maniacal laughter*

Anonymous said...

Michael

You are a wonderful person.
Screw what other people think!

Anonymous said...

I know I am late to the party but I do want to address what you wrote here, Michael. I know you and you know me and I know the individuals involved in these issues, but because I have no desire to invite negative drama into my life, I am choosing to remain anonymous for this.

I am glad you say the situation is resolved, but they never really are resolved (especially with the individuals you are dealing with who thrive on gossip and negativity.) I know you are young, idealistic, and in a school environment quite removed from reality, so this is my take from another perspective.

So, for what it's worth, as a fellow musician, here are a few points to note:

1) Why would a music teacher be upset that a student is choosing to go to university to immerse themself in music, become an educated individual, and get new perspectives on things from new people?

2) It is the test of true maturity in a teacher who truly hopes for the best for their students to recognize when they have given the student all they can and when it is time for the student to spread their wings and move on. The teacher should be confident and happy that they have prepared the student well, and then let them go! A former teacher of mine who was also a parent figure for me did this and I will forever be grateful to that teacher because it was what I needed. I am in constant touch with the teacher, still get advice from them and have a close friendship with them, with absolutely no hard feelings that I now study with someone else. In fact, this teacher practically had to push me out of the studio and refuse to let me back in order to get me to take the step I needed! I could still be with that teacher having a great time, but I would not be where I am now musically or emotionally.

3) Ask yourself why the teacher you speak of would advise you against the School of Music. Does this teacher have bad experiences with them? Is he bitter because he is not on faculty there and so feels he is less revered and respected (but no less talented) than those who are? Is he insecure about his own education and life and career path? Does he not get along with someone there? Guaranteed, he is projecting his own issues onto someone else when he tells them things like that. As I said, I know this teacher and he is very talented, very dedicated and very supportive of his students. But that comment is just wrong. What does he mean by "a student of his thought he was better than him?" Sounds like insecurity to me.... And yes, music students are obnoxious by nature (I was/am one, and it's part of the environment) but any mature musician should know and understand that is part of your development that you will move past and laugh at 10 years from now when you are teaching or doing your church job or wherever else life takes you.

4) This teacher plays a lot of mind ganes and likes control, which are a form of mental abuse. I am not trying to take away from the good in this teacher, which is considerable, but a warning - continue to watch your back, and protect yourself. Don't allow someone else's words to make you doubt yourself. I know you as a truly open, fun person - just be you. Everyone is NOT going to like that (hell, I know that personally) and so be it. Music school cliques and all that are SO unimportant. That's not to say we can't all be better people, but do it on your terms, for your reasons, guided by people you trust, as you already are - that's very mature, good for you!

5) Also beware the current students, choir members and people close to this teacher. Don't tell them anything you wouldn't want to tell the teacher to his face, and don't believe everything they tell you, no matter how good friends they say they are. Also, don't believe them when they say they don't like certain individuals. Anyone can be bought by flattery and people fulfilling their needs or saying what they want to hear.

6) Be aware that blogging can be dangerous. If you intend to be a musician, one of the most important elements of your success will be the connections you make, so never burn bridges! Start now as a student to be a person who is professional and above reproach so in 5 years when you come to get a gig, their impression of you is positive. Resist the temptation to gossip about other musicians/students/teachers etc- it is so negative and unproductive and really poisons your soul. Focus on wanting yourself to succeed, not others to fail. Ignore the people you dislike and avoid those who are negative. Be charitable about the efforts of others and be supportive of your peers. Don't say anything anywhere that could undermine any of this. You are thoughtful and passionate, so don't let the BS get in your way.

I wish you the best, Michael. Tread carefully.